World of Warcraft: Shadowlandshas finally released, taking Azeroth’s heroes through a rift to the afterlife itself as they battle to save lost souls from the Maw and the hands of the Jailer. The expansion’s events are set in motion by Forsaken founder and former Warchief Sylvanas Windrunner, who flees the Horde and destroys the Lich King’s Helm of Domination, opening a gateway to the land of the dead.
World of Warcrafthas seen faction leaders turn bad before, often to the chagrin of players who prefer the moral ambiguity of the Alliance and Horde conflict first fully explored inWarcraft 3. Not only does Sylvanas continue the trend inWorld of Warcraft: Shadowlands, but the expansion may be setting up another faction leader for a similar fate, if some quest dialog and excerpts from otherWarcraftmedia are to be believed.
RELATED:World of Warcraft: Shadowlands - How to Get Mistveil Tangle Enchanted Chest
Warchief Gone Wrong
A common criticism of Sylvanas Windrunner’s characterization in the more recentWoWexpansions has less to do with the character’s heel-turn itself, and a lot to do with the former Warchief of the Horde,Garrosh Hellscream. Garrosh took over as Warchief from Thrall, who founded the modern Horde as it exists inWoW. The change was made when Thrall stepped down after the events ofWrath of the Lich King. Many players at the time were hostile to the idea of another Warchief in general, let alone a relatively newer character like Garrosh, who had only been introduced inThe Burning Crusade.
However, over the course ofMists of PandariaandWarlords of Draenor, Garrosh went from being a hot-headed warrior to an unambiguously evil character willing to turn on the other Horde races and even his own people in pursuit of victory and revenge. While Garrosh’s prideful personality led to some conflicts in the story as soon as he was named Thrall’s successor, it was rare for Garrosh to be explicitly malevolent. The death of Tauren leader Cairne Bloodhoof, for example, was enabled by a duel with Garrosh, but was ultimately only caused by Magatha Grimtotem, a rival Tauren chieftain who poisoned Garrosh’s weapon in secret.
Garrosh would ultimately end his time as Warchief after corrupting the Vale of Eternal Blossoms and expelling the trolls from Orgrimmar, becoming the final boss ofMists of Pandariaduring the ensuing rebellion. After the death of his successor, troll leaderVol’jin, Sylvanas became Warchief. Until that point in the story, Sylvanas, like Garrosh, had been portrayed with the same moral ambiguity afforded to most of theWoWracial leaders.
Sylvanas' Descent
She may have lived in the creepy caverns of the Undercity, but Sylvanas was shown as genuinely caring for her people, the Forsaken. When some Forsaken attacked the living at the Wrath Gate inWrath of the Lich King, Sylvanas was quick to denounce them and even help Horde and Alliance forces raid the Undercity to defeat the separatist leader.
It became clear inCataclysmjust how far Sylvanas was willing to take things to create a place for her people, raising new undead using theLich King’s Val’kyr. However, while she was going to greater extremes, it made sense as a continuation of her main motive: establishing a permanent nation for the undead in the ruins of Lordaeron.
Battle for Azeroth, however, saw Sylvanas go down a very similar path to Garrosh. Like Garrosh, aspects of the Horde began disagreeing with her extreme methods, and like Garrosh she began to prioritize her own race above the others of the Horde. Eventually she would duel and killHorde veteran Varok Saurfang, abdicating her position and - perhaps most uncharacteristically - abandoning the Forsaken before fleeing to Icecrown Citadel where she initiated the events ofShadowlands.
The fact that twoHorde leaderswent down similarly villainous paths was criticized by some players who not only felt that the similarities made Sylvanas’ turn predictable, but also that the Horde’s penchant for producing villainous Warchiefs worked to oversimplify the moral ambiguity of the faction conflict. However, another faction leader may go down a dark path soon too, though this time they aren’t a member of the Horde.
RELATED:World of Warcraft: Shadowlands - Best Covenant for Every Healing Spec
King Anduin Wrynn
The young King of Stormwind,Anduin Wrynn, has been hinted to have hidden darkness within him. TheWarcraftnovelShadows Risingtalks about the immense pressure facing Anduin, and at one point Anduin even shows an affinity for Shadow magic when a “wisp of purple energy traveled down his arm, gathering in his palm” during an intense moment. Shadow magic is the opposite force to the Light the character usually invokes to cast spells, and could hint that Anduin’s desire to do good may lead him down a troublesome path.
Not only that, but Anduin is in the perfect position for his corruption inShadowlands. Captured bythe Jaileralong with some other heroes ofWarcraft, Anduin stays behind to allow the others to escape. Though he thinks he’s bested the Jailer, the villain claims that Anduin has actually given him “exactly what I need.”
What’s meant by this remains unclear, but it’s unlikely Anduin is going to emerge from his time with the Jailer mentally unscathed. By summoning the Light tothe Shadowlands, Anduin may have also revealed the possibilities of Shadow magic being used there as well, or perhaps the Light itself being used to do evil. Whatever the Jailer hopes to get from the young king, it’s unlikely that the same idealist will emerge from this expansion if he survives at all.
If Anduin is changed,Blizzardcould be setting him up to be the next faction leader to eventually becoming corrupted. Even if Anduin never turns against the Alliance, it’s likely his time in the Maw will have an affect on both him and the methods of his faction in the future, especially with other Alliance leaders like Tyrande Whisperwind and Genn Greymane desperate for revenge against the Horde for the events ofBattle for Azeroth. Though it would make a change from the Horde leaders who have gone bad so far, the studio’s storytellers will need to be very careful to make sure the MMO doesn’t feel like it’s retreading old territory.
World of Warcraft: Shadowlandsis available for PC.
MORE:10 Unresolved Mysteries and Plot Holes Left Hanging In World of Warcraft: Shadowlands
