For over a decade,Pokémonfans have been yearning for fourth-generation remakes, and to the surprise of many, the franchise answered their pleas. After much anticipation,Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearlwere released, promising to grant seasoned players a nostalgic yet modernized experience. While many fans adore the updated versions ofPokémon DiamondandPearl, others believe the experience is incomparable withoutPlatinum- the revered third game of the fourth generation.
RELATED:How Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl Differ From Other Remakes
Pokémon DiamondandPearlbear notable distinctions, yet none as substantial as those seen inPlatinum. Everything within the gameis noticeably different, from the available Pokémon to the story itself. These alterations are so significant thatPokémon Platinumis nearly unrecognizable from other fourth-generation games. However, as history reveals, third installments in a generation are left untouched - regardless of how beloved or distinguishable. Even so, there are substantial reasons whyPokémon Platinumshould get a remake.
5It Enriches The Story
Pokémon DiamondandPearlfollow the adventures of a Pokémon trainer, seeking to become the Champion of Sinnoh. The aspiring Pokémon Master’s journey leads themto Team Galactic- a morally misguided group seeking to destroy and recreate the universe. To fulfill their quest, Team Galactic must harness the godly powers ofthe Legendary PokémonDialga and Palkia. Only the trainer can thwart their schemes, ending the inadvertent calamity and chaos they have inspired.
RELATED:Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl: Hidden Side Quests You Shouldn’t Skip
Pokémon DiamondandPearlboast one of the best storylines in the franchise, whichPokémon Platinumsought to improve. It retained pertinent plot points of the original fourth-generation games while introducing numerous new elements. Such additions aimed to enrichPokémon DiamondandPearl’splot, thus, providing fans a more riveting experience. These changes madePokémon Platinum- and the fourth generation at large - among the best in the franchise. This reason alone is enough to warrant it a remake.
4It Introduces The Distortion World
Pokémon Platinumintroduces players to an alternate dimension known asthe Distortion World. This plane of existence is home to the Legendary Pokémon Giratina - a member of the Creation Trio. While the exact purpose of the Distortion World is unknown, theories suggest that it balances the universe. Thus, explaining the plane of existence’s stark differences from the natural world. The importance of the Distortion World in thePokémonuniverse - chiefly the fourth generation - is unparalleled.
RELATED:Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl: Things That Make No Sense About Team Galactic
The understandable absence of the Distortion World - except for the Distortion Room - inPokémon Brilliant DiamondandShining Pearlis wholeheartedly disappointing. This unsettling alternate dimension allows for unique plot points and a supernatural experience unlike any other. Thus, the Distortion World’s exclusion feels like a missed opportunity - one that left many fans in dismay. Only aPokémon Platinumremake could reintroduce players to the abnormal plane of existence.
3It Debuts Officer Looker
The fourth-generationPokémongames introduced many iconiccharacters like Cynthia, Cyrus, and Professor Rowan. However, only a select few maintained prominence beyond the fourth-generation games. One such character is Looker, an International Police Officer who specializes in investigating nefarious organizations. Since his appearance inPokémon Platinum, Looker has remained a prominent figure in manyPokémongames, protecting the world from numerous dangers.
RELATED:Pokemon: Forgotten Characters That Need To Come Back
Looker’s exclusion fromPokémon Brilliant DiamondandShining Pearlis unusual - considering his involvement with nefarious organizations and supernatural happenings. There is no mention of the International Police Officer anywhere, leaving many dissatisfied. InPokémon Platinum, Looker worked alongside players to thwart Team Galactic’s machinations and bring them to justice - now they must work alone. APokémon Platinumremake would debut Looker once more, thus, bolstering their experience.
2It Completes The Creation Trio
The fourth-generation features the most awe-inspiring and monumental Legendary Pokémon in the franchise. However, none are as impressive as the Creation Trio - Dialga, Palkia, and Giratina. These three Legendary Pokémon are the progenitors of the entirePokémonuniverse. They control the aspects of time (Dialga), space (Palkia), and antimatter (Giratina) - the dimensions required to create and sustain the world. To fulfill their uncompromising mission, Team Galactic requires the efforts of each Legendary Pokémon.
RELATED:The Best Legendary Pokemon (& The Worst)
Thus,Giratina’s absence formuch ofPokémon Brilliant DiamondandShining Pearlis unexpected. Rather than playing a critical role in the story, Giratina is a reward of sorts to those who acquire the National Dex. Thus, leavingPokémon Brilliant DiamondandShining Pearl’splot somewhat incomplete. Players will be unable to resolve the narrative and find solace in the game’s ending. To complete the Creation Trio and heighten the story, aPokémon Platinumremake is a must.
1It Is The Best Of Both Worlds
Pokémon Brilliant DiamondandShining Pearlbear notable distinctions - chiefly the predominant Legendary Pokémon. Therefore, distinguishing each game from one another and providing a truly unique experience. A playthrough ofPokémon Brilliant Diamondis nothing quite like one ofShining Pearl. This separation grants players a choice but limits the overall experience, unfortunately. Instead, the game provides only one side of the overarching narrative and world.
Pokémon Platinum, however, implements elements from bothDiamondandPearl. Everything from their stories to the box Legendaries themselves. Doing so makes the game well-rounded, providing players with acomplete and compellingexperience - the best of both worlds. The inclusion of aspects from both games is what garneredPokémon Platinumits popularity. So, a remake could achieve this unification of games, granting fans the all-inclusive experience presented before.
